
On a chilly winter evening, a fire breaks out in the basement of a multiple family home and quickly spreads through the building. Men, women, and children clustered by the windows, screaming for assistance; some gather the courage to jump and escape the fire. Despite the efforts of firefighters, the fire burns so quickly that tenants on the upper floors are unable to escape and perish. It is the worst residential fire New York City has seen in decades.
While this may sound like the fire that struck a townhouse in the High Bridge section of the Bronx last month, this calamity took place in 1860 in an Elm Street tenement on Manhattan’s Lower East Side. Though the two tragedies are separated by 147 years, reactions by the neighborhood and the City have been much the same. Immediately after both fires, neighbors and concerned residents throughout the City sought to assist the survivors. Like today, charitable organizations in 1860 organized relief efforts. And like today, New Yorkers focused on what had gone wrong and what could be done about it.
Like the building on Woodycrest Avenue in the Bronx, the Elm Street tenement was not considered substandard by the City. It had received no fire code violations; there was no apparatus for regularly inspecting buildings for fire safety in the winter of 1860. Except for requiring buildings to be constructed out of a fireproof material, there existed none of the fire regulations we take for granted today. No smoke alarms, sprinklers, or fire escapes existed in the tenement on Elm Street. The only means of escape provided was a narrow, wooden staircase.
Both fires initiated a civic dialogue about fire safety. In 1860, outrage about the Elm Street fire led to calls for improvements to multiple family homes “to ensure easy egress in case of fire.” Months later, the New York State legislature enacted a law requiring fire escapes on the exteriors of multiple family homes. Although it came at a terrible price, the Elm Street fire raised awareness about the need for fire safety and helped New Yorkers redefine what they considered acceptable housing.
What will be the legacy of the fire on Woodycrest Avenue?